
Four Refs take a break on the bleachers
They've got the Toughest Job in Pro Sports and the Least Respect
Officials, umps and referees receive spittle flying verbal smackdowns every time they stick their whistles in their mouth. As enforcers of "the rules" they are the bane of coaches, players, and fans alike and the two parties are bound to butt heads. The main bone of contention: unlike everybody else in the stadium or arena, the men and women in zebra stripes don't give a damn which side wins. This of course is also a glowing testament to the integrity of the profession. Refs are at their best when they're invisible, blending into the action like a chameleon on a stakeout. Here we raise a glass to these unsung athletic adjudicators who maintain the righteousness of the game.
HOCKEY
Since the NHL rule changes were instituted last year, referees have had to be more vigilant than ever before. In the past when the score was 3-3 with one-minute left to play in the third period and a player got hooked, if a ref saw the infraction but deemed it minor they'd have the discretion to let it slide. But decision making based on timeliness is all in the past and now the rules are the rules. Always. Yes, even if it's overtime in the deciding game of the Stanley Cup finals.
Two referees stalk the ice in each game, each presiding over half of the 200 by 85 foot ice surface. That doesn't mean they can take their eye off the puck or take a breather for a second if play is not in their end because if one referee gets blocked out, that extra set of eyes will be required to make the call. If they had an NHL referee skills competition, backward skating races would definitely be on the docket because going lateral fast to keep up with the action is integral to the job. Avoiding interference with the play and flying rubber bullets is another: "We as officials are out on the ice and the puck travels 120 miles per hour and it's flying everywhere—it goes off the glass, banks off boards, and deflects off goal posts and sticks. So getting out of harm's way and still being in the proper place to make call is a unique skill," explains NHL referee Kevin Pollock.
BASKETBALL
NBA officials don't tend to see eye-to-eye with the players they're presiding over. In many cases if there's a confrontation over a call they find themselves talking face to six-pack. Establishing their authority while physically keeping up with athletic thoroughbreds like Chris Bosh and LeBron James certainly keeps the hardcourt police on their toes. This could be why it takes 10-14 years overall experience before a referee will be considered for a position as an NBA official. The role of the three referees that run up and down the court for 48 minutes is not just to send guys to the foul line but to monitor the pulse of hoops action and keep players in line before they break the rules—draw the line without having to stop the play.
Oh, and to put that basketball rumour to rest that there are two sets of rules, one for rookies and one for veterans: "It's not true that rookies don't get the calls, and that you start getting calls in your second year. It's in your third year in the league that you start getting the calls," once joked NBA veteran referee Dick Bavetta who has over 2100 games under his belt.
FOOTBALL
In pro and college football, seven referees patrol the gridiron. The head referee is the one wearing a white ball cap while the rest (Head Linesman, Line Judge, Umpire, Back Judge, Side Judge, and Field Judge) are black hatters. While as a fan you may only spot the head referee when he turns on his mic to call a foul, they're in the thick of the action on every down. Before each play, the referee positions himself behind the team on offense. If it's a passing play, he'll hone in on the quarterback and the linebackers gunning for him so he'll have a prime sightline to distinguish a fumble from an incomplete pass and on running plays he'll key in on the QB and the running back and remain with them till the play is over.
"The hallmark of good officiating is for officials to know what not to call. The fouls jump out at you as an official and you are certain when they should be called. Whenever there is any doubt regarding a play, the call should not be made. Officials are so hard on themselves. When they make a mistake, nobody feels worse than they do,"-Jerry Markbreit, the only ref to preside over four Super Bowls.
This Article first ran in the November issue of Chill Magazine
Copyright © Mike Dojc 2006
No love for the Umpire? They don't wear zebra stripes, but neither do NFL refs anymore ;-)
I love umpiring coaches pitch baseball. My favorite part is the coaches and spectators who have no idea what they're talking about arguing calls with me.
Lately I've been very frustrated watching professional sports. It seems that while the boys in stripes don't care who wins, they care more about the rules than the game itself. And if that wasn't bad enough, it also seems they're getting the rules wrong.
So, I'm sorry, but I'm not saluting. (Call me when the NFL Referee Association gets its act together.)
Its 6 AM here and therefore a couple hours to early to tip the glass. I'll reread this after work and then have a Pink Squirrel in honor of the officials.
Speaking about NFL officials, I can't believe, given the speed and violence of the collisions, more officials are not injured.
Huzzah to the officials, umpires, referees, and the lot.
well, hm. yes, officiating is difficult and requires a unique skill. neither of which are excuses for making mistakes.
NFL refs are the worst of the major sports right now. hands down. and i'm a sabres fan, so i know what i'm talking about when it comes to bad officiating. they can keep @!$%#ing about how difficult their job is, they can whine as much as they want. the day will come when there will be hardly any refs on the field in football, just to call plays and blow the whistle. what is becoming literally instant replay is pushing out the need for refs not only on game progression but also in calling penalties. so as much as they whine about it being a difficult job, soon enough they won't have the job anymore.
baseball umps are also pretty bad. mostly because of their attitude. they are increasingly likely to instigate conflict with the players, which is completely unacceptable. and the NBA's policy of fining every player or coach who expresses dissatisfaction with the performance of their refs is backwards and harmful. we protect the refs and the umps far too much as it is. they arent held accountable for their actions. the players they officiate are held accountable for everything they do - on and off the field, within the realm of their play as well as after the whistle is blown. and their careers depend on everything they do. while refs may be accountable internally, it's become obvious, with the NFL and the NBA in particular, that there is little retribution for bad officiating and that the emphasis is on keeping the refs free from any pressure whatsoever from the other, primary, participants in the game.
i think the NHL refs are doing a pretty decent job, considering they are still finding their way with the new rules. i did prefer playoff hockey rules for playoffs and OT, but i can live with tight calls, as long as it's consistent, and the NHL refs are definitely erring on the side of consistency, which i have to admire.
NFL officiating is fixed, especially when my team is on the field. :)
These guys really do get a bad rap (except when my team is on the field), they compete with instant replay and oftentimes lose to the cameras. Calling them like you see 'em isn't quite good enough anymore. I also believe there are way too many rules, I think they should should let the players play, so what if he touched another player, if they're so talented they can still catch it.
Thanks for the article - I'll remember this on Sunday.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |